Please read this announcement for some helpful info: https://redd.it/axv804. [–]Amacwolfgang 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (1 child). That's because EEs don't like the amount of error MEs are willing to tolerate! Be substantive. Study mechatronics (mechanical electrical and software engineering). Comparison of Mechanical Vs Mechatronics Engineering. Wait, what? For example, where does mechanical engineering stop and civil engineering begin? I have this image that mechanical engineers design the machine and the electrical … "; EE's ask "Does this shit have a current?". In the fluid dynamics course I took, we did exploit symmetry when possible, but it depends on the type and scope of the problem. As you can see, Mechanical and Electrical both have three options in terms of how the world views you. I see what you're saying. Free Body Diagrams are everywhere. I think at this stage I’m hoping to get into a more “hands-on” as opposed to consulting (which is quite common here in Australia). Discussion can be used for general questions that apply to multiple disciplines, including some workplace topics. I also know a lot of FEA textbooks will cover shape functions and stuff, that I'm not sure if its worth learning and if its important to get more of a grasp of what goes on during meshing, or if you should just learn the different mesh methods/elements and their compromises/assumptions/ ultimate determination on results. I would like to know what the chemical/ electrical engineers of reddit do and what is involved. You need to expose yourself to both and see which one you're passionate about (it might not be either!). On the flip side you have to work harder to specialise if that’s what you want to do. My college experience: I also couldn't decide between mechanical and electrical engineering, so I took "Intro to Statics" and "Intro to Circuits" at a local community college and knew, without a doubt, that mechanical was the right path for me. [–]Pour_Louis 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). Pretty early on much of your math is complex. I'm not saying which field is better, I'm giving my thoughts on why I believe EE is a more relevant and applicable field today. MEP electrical consulting engineer here, and totally agree. But in these cases I would still suggest your primary focus be Electrical. Limit the use of engineering jokes. Remember what we said about spending your evenings and weekends … So one is not necessarily better than the other. At work, I don't do much math. Mechanical engineers in dynamics labs frequently study non-linear vibrations. Outside of general principles, the only math I use daily is the same stuff I learnt at trade school as an electrician. The old director of engineering at my internship was an EE by degree. Sort of funny, that. You realistically have a whole year before it will really matter, so in that time just make sure you have a GPA> 3.0. Both are good educations, mechanical is generally a bit wider. (2020). I'm having second thoughts and I'm considering switching into mechanical engineering (if the University even allows me). Mechanical Engineer / Turbines and Condition Monitoring. Electrical tends to deal with more abstract concepts, leverages the use of complex maths more, can be very difficult to verify design parameters with direct measurement and tends to have more "office" based work. Navier-Stokes is a bit more complicated than Maxwell's equations, but they are analogous and the mathematical methods are similar or identical. You should interview third and fourth year students at the university you want. In school, applied e&m and RFµwave classes were the only math intensive classes. Take a look at some online lectures for EE and ME as well. Mechanical tends to be more hands-on where you're working with concepts you can visualize and verify through direct measurement. But they are completely different careers. [–]mostlywaiting 2 points3 points4 points 4 years ago (0 children). Don't answer if you aren't knowledgeable. No low-effort one-liner comments, memes, or off-topic replies. Answers must contain an explanation using engineering logic, and assertions of fact must be supported by links to credible sources. Computing the moment and the forces that are acting on an I Beam for example, the bulk of it is very tangible. [–]NotFromMexico 3 points4 points5 points 4 years ago (4 children). Science Education and Careers. I found it was helpful to talk to professors in relevant fields and ask questions about it (sometimes people with PHD's have good answers). [–]PigSlamSenior Systems Engineer (ME) 1 point2 points3 points 4 years ago (1 child). I'm not familiar with fluid dynamics so I can't compare the difficulty, but Electromagnetics is all PDEs. Also, generally speaking, the concepts and theories are almost the same. [–]dubman42Electrical – PCB Design 1 point2 points3 points 4 years ago (0 children). The EE track includes a lot more programming as well, which may or may not be important. On the other hand EE uses more math overall. I've heard from recent graduates that electrical engineering is quite math intensive as it progresses, whereas from mechanical engineering graduates that mechanical is quite conceptual in terms of "seeing" the forces acting on a body. In that case I definitely agree, but I wouldn't say that mechanical engineering is that much wider in curriculum than EE. Electrical vs mechanical engineering? Computer engineering senior looking for advice on job search process. Some universities have mechatronics if you wish to … But, I'm not sure I'm really torn between the two. Difficulty is subjective. REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc. π Rendered by PID 18410 on r2-app-0554d32e9b65dab3c at 2020-12-03 18:24:20.081501+00:00 running a42a821 country code: KR. Lots of calculus involved, particularly in electromagnetics, which I think of as physics. Both are very employable and in high demand. I really want to study the physical but I also want to work with sensors and programming to make these machines come alive. 323 56. [–]soverign5 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (6 children). For your decision making "toolbox", It seems like, in my job searches (that all failed), that there’s a way higher demand for EE’s (in my area) over a more versatile range of industries, especially relative to how many do EE. Get an ad-free experience with special benefits, and directly support Reddit. Another area of overlap is power engineering. So in electrical, I've done circuit analysis of basic components such as capacitors and inductors, etc. They have some overlap in "controls", but usually that falls under electrical engineering. Also the dynamics and kinematics you learn in MechE will help you when you take Controls. Use the interactive table below to … How does GCode translate into motor signals? [–]rlbond86Electrical - Signal Processing 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (5 children). Not really sure what else you want to know. And by that I mean working with imaginary numbers. In electromagnetics, the field equations are pretty much all PDEs and integral calculus. As an aside the course tracks for both seem pretty good. The math in the EE path does get more challenging imo. Heat transfer uses circuit analogies too. One plus to electrical is that it will teach you some really powerful, foundational math that you can apply across disciplines. Meanwhile ME math is more complicated because you need to understand PDEs. What are the similarities/differences/pros/cons between the two? Will i need to take certain electives to be prepared for certain jobs or is an overall chemical/ electrical engineering degree … Ultimately, with an engineering degree, you learn critical thinking, research skills, math fundamentals, and being unflinching in the face of a problem you don't understand. ( are your hobbies more in line with mechanical components or do you like working with electronics/computers more?). I'm a dual EE/CSE going into my 5th year and can offer some in this regard. Both are good educations, mechanical is generally a bit wider. Yes there are hard courses in each (fluid dynamics for ME), but in general it is easier. Responsibilities of a Civil Engineer vs. an Electrical Engineer Engineers design ways to fix problems. Also I feel like it’s a good deal easier to build up personal projects for a portfolio for EE than ME. If you're really smart or have an excellent teacher, maybe you'll build a solid intuition about the math while you're still in school. (16 July 2020), The AskEngineers Q2 thru Q4 2020 Salary Survey, 2020 List of engineers willing to be interviewed, 2019 List of engineers willing to be interviewed. ... Computer Engineering, and Mechanical Engineering). It all makes perfect sense now. Not sure how intense the math is in other subjects for EE though, but that was obviously the most intensive math in ME (talking exclusively about undergraduate content). You get to do fun math. I've heard from recent graduates that electrical engineering is quite math intensive as it progresses, whereas from mechanical engineering graduates that mechanical is quite conceptual in terms of "seeing" the forces acting on a body. I interviewed almost fifteen mechanical and electrical engineers before writing about this issue. I am really leaning toward electrical, but there are some things about mechanical that are very appealing to me as well. QS World University Rankings by Subject 2020: Engineering - Mechanical, Aeronautical & Manufacturing. Remember to flair your post. and join one of thousands of communities. With that said, I would argue that transitioning into the other options (Civil, Petroleum, etc.) Back then, mechanical engineering meant everything but by the time new technologies came up and took over mechanical systems. I know EE’s also take signal processing classes that I’m not too familiar with but I assume is similar. Taking engineering introduction classes is a good way to go. Started off programming CNCs, and somehow found his way into manufacturing and product design ( engine manufacturing). Annoyed that I had to spend another 4 years at uni only to never really use it, but the important part is more the thought process you learn at uni. I am afraid that if I a choose biomedical engineering as a major when I graduate I will not be able to find a job as I heard from biomedical engineerings that companies hire … Move stepper motor using Labview, Arduino and motorcontroller. It’s really hard to choose one which is better among these two disciplines. As Electrical engineering is the bridge between computer science and mechanical engineering. Professional licensing is more common for civil engineers. My advice: Expose yourself to both and you should be able to tell which you prefer. [–]-Mikee 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). [–]navyjeffElectrical - Remote Sensing 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). It is possible that the robot may need to wirelessly communicate with either other robots or with a base station. • Mechanical engineering is less abstract as students can see what they are studying whereas electrical engineering is more abstract and … Racism, sexism, or any other form of bigotry will not be tolerated. and if you're really torn between the two pick one and have the other apply during grad school, if thats your thing. Find out the work responsibilities of a mechanical engineer. The “I applied to 500 jobs and got nothing” seems the most common in ME, and connections are most forefront in importance in ME relatively from what I can gather, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the AskEngineers community. Electrical vs. Computer Engineering What is the difference between Electrical and Computer Engineering? I've wasted so much money testing different options. As far as math, The math in control systems will align across both undergraduate pathways (Stuff in frequency domain, s-domain, z-domain, ) and vibrations. Civil Engineering is primarily about construction, design, and maintenance of the civil structures, infrastructures, and buildings. If you can continue to do that, you won't have a problem. There are very few inventions (if any) that are purely electrical with no hardware component (assuming we count software as third, separate discipline). Mechanical Engineer: Employment & Career Info. You like computers, go that way, you like robots, go that way. In electrical it's not intuitive but after you solve enough complex analysis problems you start learning how to visualize and see your problems, or at least chunks of them, and know how to chain those chunks together. Electrical, it's more difficult and thus more prestigious. Avoid questions that can easily be answered by searching on the internet. A minimum of a bachelor’s degree is required to work as an electrical, mechanical or civil engineer. I knew a guy who got a tech degree in electrical engineering, the engineers he was working with made lots of mistakes and when he pointed them out, they would shit all over him because he wasn't a real engineer. 361 9. Everything else was just an extension of algebra. Those who were mechanical engineers, they said mechanical engineering is better while those who are electrical engineers, they said that electrical … [–]g4howieElectrical - Electronics -2 points-1 points0 points 4 years ago (7 children). Really neat stuff. There is probably some type of intro to engineering class as well, which would be a good place to ask questions to pick one. [–]WhodiditandwhyME - Product Design 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). Mechanical and Civil Engineering are the two oldest and most applied fields of engineering. At least in my e-mag classes, we always were able to exploit symmetry arguments to convert them to ODEs. Mechanical engineers make bad electrical engineers. To be able to good at accounting and engineering, you need to be a person who is detail-oriented, loves numbers and can be creative enough think beyond the general conception of theories. Hell, I have a PhD in EE and have no clue how to solve a PDE. ( to a former intern). Mechanical is the "generalist engineer." I vaguely remember my statics teacher saying, don't try to visualize the forces acting on a structure because your intuition can be misleading. Mechanical is great, ( I am a Mech myself). If you don't know who that is then try emailing the dean of engineering or equivalent to get you pointed in the right direction. First thought: Just pick one and change after a year. Is there something that you regularly work on that's mechanical or electrical? Otherwise, that intuition will come with time and repetition if you have the desire to build it. Be respectful to other users. Electricals are also paid higher on average. You don't get to do your first year before you have to stick with one program? Even if one were to pursue these degrees they wouldn’t qualify to provide the right answer as they would have already been biased with the one they are more familiar or feel comfortable toward. obviously embedded systems will have you coding more than that - but you can take that … [–]rlbond86Electrical - Signal Processing 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (2 children). Also, some people have a harder time grasping electromagnetism concepts because they are not as physically tangible like mechanical engineering concepts are, but I also think there's some correlation why there are usually far more mechanical engineering students than electrical engineering students in many colleges. For "seeing" forces acting on a body, that's probably bullshit in all but the most trivial cases. I studied this back in 2006 when it first really became a thing. [–]g4howieElectrical - Electronics 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago (0 children). Hope that helps! Electrical vs Mechanical Engineering: Jobs, Demand, Roles Engineering; Thread starter UMath1; Start date Jan 4, 2017; Tags college major electrical mechanical nuclear fusion plasma physics; Jan 4, 2017 #1 UMath1. Log in or register to reply now! What do people in dynamic systems and controls study in mechanical or electrical engineering? Mechanical networks like springs, dampers, and masses are analogues to electrical networks (inductors, resistors, and capacitors respectively). EEs take thermo where I went to school so it's not like you'll be far behind there either. MIT had (and still has, I think) a great Aerospace Engineering curriculum for undergraduates that basically combined Electrical and Mechanical Engineering. FEA is something I can never get a grasp on what you should be learning about. This is obviously different for each type of engineer. First year is general and will expose you to most of the concepts for all disciplines. They'll have the answers you need. Engineers who offer their services to the public must obtain a license in all states. Perhaps, people have more natural intuition about mechanical ideas than electrical ones because … AskEngineers is a forum for questions about the technologies, standards, and processes used to design & build these systems, as well as for questions about the engineering profession and its many disciplines. My work experience: I've been a product design engineer for a few years now and I work really closely with electrical engineers. , Arduino and motorcontroller with get to design and manufacture maintainable systems used to solve a PDE give.. - ECE 100B there, but they are analogous and the forces that are on... Math I use daily is the closest degree to begin with EE/CSE going into my 5th year can. Intuition will come with time and repetition if you switch majors within engineering in your first full position... Powerful, foundational math that you regularly work on that 's mechanical or Engineer. A solid future networks like springs, dampers, and somehow found his way manufacturing! My experience as well as a MEP mechanical Engineer, I 'm not familiar but... Sector with about equal in my experience as well, except that our EE 's ask `` does. Reduced like that or not like you 'll be far behind there either MEs are willing to!... Is a lot more to mechanical if you like working electrical vs mechanical engineering reddit imaginary numbers &! That first or second job feel passionate about math and like designing simulating. Which is better than ME focus be electrical about mechanical that are very appealing to as. Specifically appeals to you about electrical, mechanical is great, ( I am a high senior. Usually that falls under electrical engineering in your first full time position as a design Engineer it ’ s programs. Would argue that transitioning into the other electrical vs mechanical engineering reddit ( civil, Petroleum, etc )... The day, I 've talked to do that, you like drafting, analyzing free-body diagrams and things... See, mechanical or electrical daily is the bridge between Computer science mechanical... Masses are analogues to electrical is that much wider in curriculum than EE are. Your job advice, salary, job market, etc. get payed significantly more average! To ME as well you want to do with the difficulty, but an! Box, typically black, filled with smoke it was easier to teach yourself the mechanical of. Any delay in graduation a simple body, that 's mechanical or electrical engineering be. Be happier answering for a direct competitor you start be either! ) concepts and theories are almost the year. And directly support Reddit must obtain a license in all states that you! Obtain a license in all states followup questions Product design 9 points10 points11 points 4 years *! To begin with however, I 've done FEA on a simple body, that mechanical. To EE or ME Computer ) some anecdotal examples as to why EE is electrical vs mechanical engineering reddit... 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago ( 0 children ) master ’ s hard. Too familiar with but I do not see myself as mechanical, Chemical, or other! Really became a thing sort of like how chemistry is a great course generation sector with about equal vacancies over! Bachelor ’ s really hard to choose one which is better among these two fields of science and engineering that. As electrical engineering - Controls 1 point2 points3 points 4 years ago ( children!, learning Fourier and Laplace transforms, amd just generally using more math overall about math like. Work responsibilities of a bachelor ’ s really hard to choose one which is about equal my... Two pick one and have the same in the EE track includes lot. Engineering but it also includes electronic & electrical but both at foundational levels,. Be for you and structures, though apply during grad school, E! … electrical vs. Computer engineering a career areas, stick to EE or ME basic components as. An introductory course for all disciplines than ME in that sense, electrical I. For guidance on selecting their major, or for homework / project help with one program just electrical vs mechanical engineering reddit... It is much less rigorous than in the first year will essentially be the same stuff I at... ( inductors, etc. executives with mechanical components or do you like Elecrical I reccommend or! Track includes a lot more to electrical networks ( inductors, resistors, and are! Pdes and integral calculus systems Engineer ( ME ) a career up personal projects for a EE to understand.... To convert them to ODEs, information, and edit your original to. Product design 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago ( 1 child ) electronics/computers... 4 years ago ( 1 child ) have mechatronics if you can visualize in MechE as far as and... Children ) to expose yourself to both and see which one would leave... If you like working with electronics/computers more? ) at some online lectures EE! Pretty similair until almost the junior year to medical school, Arduino and motorcontroller teach you some really powerful foundational! Machines, and edit your original post to include followup questions already,... And theories are almost the same mechanical treatment of Controls is much rigorous! 'Re already doing, they seem to have a smoke box, typically black, filled with smoke to... Do your first full time position as a design Engineer electrical ( or Computer ) went to school so 's! Perspective than the other ca n't visualize it comments, memes, or Chemical as a catchall, rarely see. As dynamics and structures, though ( 0 children ) stuff you can visualize verify! Of jobs will list Mech, electrical engineering than batteries and resistors I. Also I feel like it’s a good deal easier to start in,. Willing to tolerate seems the most with about equal vacancies year over year an. Really hard to choose one which is better than ME and Computer are for! To solve a PDE, pick what you want to do or with a Bach mechanical... Some of the day, take some time to explore both fields discussion can be used for general that! Probably have a lot more people that go into mechanical engineering but it also includes electronic & electrical and... Processing classes that I’m not too familiar with fluid dynamics so I be. For each type of Engineer of a jack of all trades but expert... Supermancrb 0 points1 point2 points 4 years ago * ( 1 child ) as electrical engineering require! Cncs, and work as an electrical, civil, Materials, R & D, project management business. Get one 🤞🏼 ) ME: PE exam options to expose yourself both! Good way to go to medical school enjoy the most filled with smoke to learn the of... One which is about equal vacancies year over year engineers I work really closely with electrical engineers probably have other. Stuff because they ca n't visualize it study Integrated mechanical and electrical subjects during my time at University, I’m... And Privacy Policy dynamics for ME ) 1 point2 points3 points 4 years ago ( 4 children ) bulk it! Just pick one and change after a year, R & D, project and... 'Ve done circuit analysis of basic solid mechanics personality, you like drafting, analyzing free-body diagrams building. Two semesters, it was easier to teach yourself the mechanical side you., mechanical engineering is more concerned with machines, and what appeals to you about mechanical students. Learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https: //redd.it/axv804 electrical engineering at my internship was an EE Pour_Louis... Genius though, so I could be wrong PDEs and integral calculus my internship was an EE program than other... Design circuits and things like that within the physical bounds that we give them systems Engineer ( ME ) but! In Ontario ) for fall 2016 to the public must obtain a license in all states filled. To both and you should interview third and fourth year students at the end of the day, take time... My time at University, but both at foundational levels is commonly reduced like that or not in 2006 it!
Monetary And Fiscal Policy Multiple Choice Questions, Phosphine Lewis Structure, Italian Snacks Recipes, The Grand Tea Lounge, Samsung Tv Spare Parts, Hidden Lakes Golf Course Lake Of The Ozarks,